Amber Miller home

Accessibility and Inclusive Design

Accessibility audit slides, inclusive persona cards, and workshop artefacts used to identify barriers and educate teams

What happens when a customer needs to change their pension details but can’t get through the contact form?

No time to read the full case study?

Skip to outcomes

I conducted an accessibility audit of a legacy service, using inclusive personas and assistive technology testing to uncover usability barriers. By translating WCAG issues into human stories, I helped stakeholders understand the impact and sparked wider internal conversations about accessibility.

90+ issues identified
100 internal requests
Workshop for 30 colleagues

Backstory

During a quieter period at work, my manager asked me to investigate one of our legacy services and identify opportunities for improvement.

The service was a contact form attached to our public website. It was aimed at users of our legacy software and had very low traffic, so appetite for improvement was low.

My brief was open: get to know the service and recommend what to tackle first.

I chose to make personas a central theme of this project so I could stay accountable to a broad range of user needs.

Planning

Testing plan

How I tested

  • Reviewed the form against usability heuristics to establish a baseline.
  • Listened to the form with a screen reader.
  • Navigated using only the keyboard.
  • Checked the form on a mobile phone.

Tasks I tested

  1. Find out which support topics are available.
  2. Complete a “Change my personal details” request.
  3. Complete a “Nomination of beneficiaries” request.

Inclusive personas

Assumed Sam

Sam has no perceived accessibility needs, and accesses the platform from her home computer, equipped with a keyboard, mouse and high-speed internet connection.

Illustration of example user
Understanding our assumed user

Our assumed user is thought to face no barriers in how they access our products. They are thought to be in good health, neurotypical, able-bodied, and have access to a good-quality computer and high-speed internet. We also assume they have set aside time to complete their tasks and will not face any external disturbances. These assumptions allow them the use of a mouse and keyboard.

Key needs
  • An intuitive, well-designed user experience Logical instructions and forms to complete desired actions quickly and efficiently
  • Signposting to any further actions required
1 of 5

Findings

Choosing what to show stakeholders

In a week I found around 90 issues, from missing keyboard focus indicators to misleading language. Business leaders needed to understand what those issues meant for a customer trying to complete a request.

I used the personas from my testing plan to connect each technical finding to a task. For example, a page title like “Customer Request Container” gives Sam little help finding the form again after opening another tab to look up their plan number.

Letting people hear the problem

The most effective part of my presentation was a screen recording. An asterisk marked a required field. The screen reader spent more than a minute announcing its alternative text.

Playing the recording let stakeholders hear how long someone had to wait to reach the next part of the form.

Example audit findings

What changed after the audit

The slide deck containing my audit, while originally intended for a small group of immediate stakeholders, gained traction internally as an example of how we should be addressing accessibility concerns and why it matters. To date, I've received over 100 access requests from senior leaders throughout the business to help them understand our issues and empathise with them, including members of the C-suite.

I've also shared this presentation with other departments including technology and product management to help them better understand some of the accessibility concerns, and prevent them from being repeated in the future


Since presenting my audit, we've seen much earlier UX involvement in initiatives, as we've proven the value of our input early on for preventing rework like this.

Turning personas into flashcards

To keep momentum going, I took the personas, the most requested part of my audit, and turned them into easily shareable flashcards highlighting different users and their needs. I was able to collaborate with our vulnerable customers lead to understand some more niche vulnerability scenarios affecting our contact strategy, to build a more robust persona list.

The idea behind the cards was simple and functioned a bit like a Top Trumps, allowing anyone interested to pick a card at random and learn a bit more about a vulnerability they might not have thought about before.

The cards were designed to work both as a standalone learning activity, but also to be incorporated into some accessibility and inclusive design training planned.

Accessibility flashcards

Illustrated portrait of Nyla

Nyla

Illustrator, 32

Nyla is a freelance illustrator based in Leeds. She has Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, a connective tissue disorder which affects her joints, skin and energy levels.

Some days her condition is well managed, and can live her life to the full without thinking about it.

Illustrated portrait of Marcia

Marcia

Teacher, 54

Marcia is a teacher in Greater Manchester, where she lives with her husband and teenage sons. She fell victim to an online scam last year, which saw her lose over two thousand pounds.

She has struggled with a great deal of shame after the scam, and feels very foolish.

Illustrated portrait of Pierre

Pierre

Gardener, 39

Pierre moved to Edinburgh from Lyon, France with his wife and children three years ago when his wife received a promotion.

He speaks conversational English, but struggles with the written language. He particularly struggles with formal language on official documents, and gets easily frustrated trying to use websites with too many words.

Inclusive design workshop

At our most recent team day, featuring 30 participants across design, research and management, I took the opportunity to run an inclusive design training workshop inspired by my findings.

I designed a hands-on accessibility training workshop to help teams experience the barriers different users face, building skills from empathy rather than from textbooks.

This workshop involved splitting into teams and receiving two persona cards, detailing realistic and relatable barriers like language, chronic health or money worries, and a common situation they had to design for.

Inclusive design workshop output from a team exercise

Design ideas produced during the inclusive design workshop

Reach of the audit

  • 90+ accessibility and usability issues found in production legacy code
  • 100 access requests from across the organisation for my audit findings
  • I used the findings to run a workshop for 30 UX researchers, designers, managers and senior leadership

What I learned

I went into the audit thinking the challenge was finding the barriers. Explaining their impact took just as much care. A screen recording gave colleagues a way to experience the delay for themselves, and the persona cards gave them a way to bring that perspective into their next design discussion.